{ "generated_at": "2026-04-29T17:26:34+00:00", "harness": "snhp/b2b_round_robin.py (multi-attribute SAO, NegMAS)", "config": { "n_rounds": 20, "n_steps": 10, "randomize_steps": true, "batna_center": 0.4, "batna_range": 0.08, "must_deal_base_prob": 0.1, "n_workers": 14, "total_wall_seconds": 57.3 }, "extra_players": [], "markets": { "symmetric": { "wall_seconds": 17.8, "seller_pressure": 1.0, "buyer_pressure": 1.0, "rankings": [ { "name": "The Closer", "avg": 0.5289374686929171, "med": 0.5800214717209639, "min": 0.30142145516752505, "max": 0.6888639863786788, "ci_lo": 0.4752133711436536, "ci_hi": 0.5805354513199767, "elo": 1459.480110321599, "wins": 9, "ties": 0, "losses": 11 }, { "name": "Logroller", "avg": 0.5122072883695722, "med": 0.576660376254095, "min": 0.1919351626645267, "max": 0.6700919541020416, "ci_lo": 0.43976886994650627, "ci_hi": 0.5716833886585799, "elo": 1502.9520889113062, "wins": 8, "ties": 0, "losses": 12 }, { "name": "Principled", "avg": 0.5077286309855837, "med": 0.5548152477876283, "min": 0.15098786449319307, "max": 0.6557081401680603, "ci_lo": 0.4408875775188089, "ci_hi": 0.5629960274377331, "elo": 1381.994633244333, "wins": 5, "ties": 0, "losses": 15 }, { "name": "GoodCop/BadCop", "avg": 0.5066954092941891, "med": 0.562776372005251, "min": 0.28879206529934326, "max": 0.6774609515884924, "ci_lo": 0.4385942757548713, "ci_hi": 0.5699766299325776, "elo": 1551.3313665032847, "wins": 13, "ties": 0, "losses": 7 }, { "name": "SNHP", "avg": 0.5013083611801757, "med": 0.532491631614649, "min": 0.2665860912171533, "max": 0.6203729226056504, "ci_lo": 0.4531084574710557, "ci_hi": 0.5435899771402185, "elo": 1331.2908501321044, "wins": 1, "ties": 1, "losses": 18 }, { "name": "Nibbler", "avg": 0.5003624643614862, "med": 0.5661575911377469, "min": 0.1909327931288366, "max": 0.6977356124083156, "ci_lo": 0.42609402945682806, "ci_hi": 0.5696251167785934, "elo": 1489.2546321948448, "wins": 9, "ties": 0, "losses": 11 }, { "name": "Sunk Cost", "avg": 0.4943838843251317, "med": 0.5153770490046261, "min": 0.28359508897527935, "max": 0.7191677835165804, "ci_lo": 0.4454526343227137, "ci_hi": 0.5444824953942853, "elo": 1339.547140497348, "wins": 5, "ties": 0, "losses": 15 }, { "name": "Split-the-Diff", "avg": 0.4903348800587039, "med": 0.4956227063302518, "min": 0.2116033119477122, "max": 0.6366183679292658, "ci_lo": 0.4378013495237113, "ci_hi": 0.5407002212373614, "elo": 1266.3530619481219, "wins": 1, "ties": 1, "losses": 18 }, { "name": "Fairness Norm", "avg": 0.48880748734114166, "med": 0.5309259205081449, "min": 0.20582817877768889, "max": 0.6104341718558318, "ci_lo": 0.435162578708308, "ci_hi": 0.5324969522741873, "elo": 1206.3979915674809, "wins": 3, "ties": 0, "losses": 17 }, { "name": "Deadline Exploiter", "avg": 0.48672521687975095, "med": 0.5122896569947261, "min": 0.12881265203908726, "max": 0.8014396367079828, "ci_lo": 0.4014423616829277, "ci_hi": 0.5676066429934552, "elo": 1610.4813200641565, "wins": 18, "ties": 1, "losses": 1 }, { "name": "Anchorer", "avg": 0.4832682092390294, "med": 0.4984592930568581, "min": 0.1663556517231016, "max": 0.7398852268197105, "ci_lo": 0.4005117390652385, "ci_hi": 0.5675181744401308, "elo": 1667.3809035021645, "wins": 15, "ties": 0, "losses": 5 }, { "name": "Cialdini", "avg": 0.4815738918147535, "med": 0.5408572656426773, "min": 0.1589007973523799, "max": 0.7317510246256171, "ci_lo": 0.401199627782621, "ci_hi": 0.559135870819656, "elo": 1622.0569250886049, "wins": 12, "ties": 0, "losses": 8 }, { "name": "Tactical Empath", "avg": 0.47660607893966933, "med": 0.5379964627349021, "min": 0.17104255296900367, "max": 0.6621161769754766, "ci_lo": 0.41164153596222447, "ci_hi": 0.5346786702765273, "elo": 1352.9728724691315, "wins": 7, "ties": 0, "losses": 13 }, { "name": "Aspiration", "avg": 0.47552313935972507, "med": 0.521874499709174, "min": 0.1731274123922778, "max": 0.7924211439529223, "ci_lo": 0.39507188733131327, "ci_hi": 0.5566245598826158, "elo": 1595.0811663819688, "wins": 14, "ties": 3, "losses": 3 }, { "name": "Fair Demand", "avg": 0.4441461351277069, "med": 0.5347920409686988, "min": 0.1567282213822137, "max": 0.5898857412067492, "ci_lo": 0.37444112910900146, "ci_hi": 0.5080128975583902, "elo": 1256.6354379060786, "wins": 1, "ties": 0, "losses": 19 }, { "name": "Reciprocity", "avg": 0.443374805628205, "med": 0.49536285827489923, "min": 0.16788104282190758, "max": 0.7590151290378342, "ci_lo": 0.3630166233428806, "ci_hi": 0.5275358157271938, "elo": 1621.030312128781, "wins": 12, "ties": 0, "losses": 8 }, { "name": "BATNA Bluffer", "avg": 0.44273527542903796, "med": 0.4871593030356865, "min": 0.1275396739055358, "max": 0.7696382516400316, "ci_lo": 0.3551956561670499, "ci_hi": 0.5302109834776347, "elo": 1602.5978876927052, "wins": 11, "ties": 0, "losses": 9 }, { "name": "Soviet Patience", "avg": 0.42376846269257396, "med": 0.46333888109971555, "min": 0.14828369146578307, "max": 0.7659201867369148, "ci_lo": 0.3494684773976117, "ci_hi": 0.5094581581300129, "elo": 1648.9678647870885, "wins": 15, "ties": 2, "losses": 3 }, { "name": "Silent Hardliner", "avg": 0.3849411655615852, "med": 0.36631430906776574, "min": 0.14205451822077353, "max": 0.7088298022701945, "ci_lo": 0.31675991677355236, "ci_hi": 0.45918245935029084, "elo": 1622.9557906097084, "wins": 13, "ties": 1, "losses": 6 }, { "name": "Anchoring Bias", "avg": 0.381858118190131, "med": 0.37001689855200215, "min": 0.13280678995486497, "max": 0.7952190864031858, "ci_lo": 0.3100996122690965, "ci_hi": 0.4583800274602914, "elo": 1747.658198981518, "wins": 16, "ties": 1, "losses": 3 }, { "name": "Loss Averse", "avg": 0.33058358879271316, "med": 0.29800103467356587, "min": 0.149580010018082, "max": 0.5851332275868674, "ci_lo": 0.2774317044165436, "ci_hi": 0.38199200277571554, "elo": 1623.5794450676715, "wins": 16, "ties": 2, "losses": 2 } ], "pairwise": [ { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.3345, "b_util": 0.334, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.4985, "b_util": 0.4322, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.3731, "b_util": 0.3251, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.3039, "b_util": 0.3052, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.4068, "b_util": 0.4258, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.6089, "b_util": 0.5443, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.6949, "b_util": 0.5821, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.4959, "b_util": 0.3446, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.6899, "b_util": 0.5272, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3226, "b_util": 0.3285, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5963, "b_util": 0.5635, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.6258, "b_util": 0.5443, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.7157, "b_util": 0.4851, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.1828, "b_util": 0.2083, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5774, "b_util": 0.5034, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.207, "b_util": 0.2106, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.7389, "b_util": 0.5336, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.1896, "b_util": 0.1795, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7399, "b_util": 0.4255, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6801, "b_util": 0.4801, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.1664, "b_util": 0.1424, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.3939, "b_util": 0.4598, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5887, "b_util": 0.5832, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.5034, "b_util": 0.536, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.1909, "b_util": 0.2396, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5176, "b_util": 0.5559, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.6207, "b_util": 0.6273, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.6373, "b_util": 0.5867, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6415, "b_util": 0.5369, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.646, "b_util": 0.5914, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2712, "b_util": 0.2695, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.4445, "b_util": 0.455, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5662, "b_util": 0.6055, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6977, "b_util": 0.4959, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.4467, "b_util": 0.4241, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6106, "b_util": 0.5771, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2929, "b_util": 0.2706, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6629, "b_util": 0.5447, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.265, "b_util": 0.2318, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.6266, "b_util": 0.542, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6691, "b_util": 0.5708, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.2142, "b_util": 0.2572, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.2505, "b_util": 0.3001, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5613, "b_util": 0.4702, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.443, "b_util": 0.422, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.1947, "b_util": 0.2214, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.3736, "b_util": 0.3299, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.2199, "b_util": 0.1635, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.6339, "b_util": 0.5099, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5383, "b_util": 0.4666, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5737, "b_util": 0.4899, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.1538, "b_util": 0.1402, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.4872, "b_util": 0.4552, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.6343, "b_util": 0.5449, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.738, "b_util": 0.4987, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.2187, "b_util": 0.2355, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5295, "b_util": 0.4807, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1275, "b_util": 0.1415, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6501, "b_util": 0.5194, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2039, "b_util": 0.1746, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7696, "b_util": 0.4259, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6893, "b_util": 0.4913, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.3066, "b_util": 0.2797, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.2695, "b_util": 0.2474, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5149, "b_util": 0.4089, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.4026, "b_util": 0.378, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.1836, "b_util": 0.1668, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.2359, "b_util": 0.2301, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.2328, "b_util": 0.2333, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.3587, "b_util": 0.3109, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.4653, "b_util": 0.3608, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5214, "b_util": 0.4328, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2779, "b_util": 0.2929, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.4729, "b_util": 0.4077, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.383, "b_util": 0.3353, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6936, "b_util": 0.4775, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.2804, "b_util": 0.2531, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.3663, "b_util": 0.3356, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1771, "b_util": 0.1364, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.5632, "b_util": 0.4872, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.1421, "b_util": 0.1705, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7088, "b_util": 0.3674, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.5365, "b_util": 0.4478, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.2973, "b_util": 0.3099, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.3136, "b_util": 0.2403, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5684, "b_util": 0.5456, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.2604, "b_util": 0.2706, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.3611, "b_util": 0.354, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.2524, "b_util": 0.2367, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.4557, "b_util": 0.4034, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5415, "b_util": 0.4849, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.4954, "b_util": 0.3745, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.6594, "b_util": 0.5659, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.206, "b_util": 0.2059, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5749, "b_util": 0.5397, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5582, "b_util": 0.526, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6934, "b_util": 0.4644, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.2123, "b_util": 0.1809, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5478, "b_util": 0.5067, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.173, "b_util": 0.1709, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6439, "b_util": 0.5482, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.1831, "b_util": 0.1987, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.759, "b_util": 0.5183, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6835, "b_util": 0.576, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.1679, "b_util": 0.1568, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.3497, "b_util": 0.4152, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5455, "b_util": 0.5826, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.3945, "b_util": 0.4458, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2888, "b_util": 0.2834, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.374, "b_util": 0.3471, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.6073, "b_util": 0.5996, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.6445, "b_util": 0.6184, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6644, "b_util": 0.5314, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.6775, "b_util": 0.6068, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3553, "b_util": 0.3783, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5628, "b_util": 0.5722, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5934, "b_util": 0.5926, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6654, "b_util": 0.4721, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.3776, "b_util": 0.4098, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6224, "b_util": 0.5652, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2888, "b_util": 0.277, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6491, "b_util": 0.5262, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.3095, "b_util": 0.2721, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.6504, "b_util": 0.562, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6461, "b_util": 0.527, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.3739, "b_util": 0.3544, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.3484, "b_util": 0.3932, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.58, "b_util": 0.6085, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.5198, "b_util": 0.5757, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.4075, "b_util": 0.4281, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.4383, "b_util": 0.4562, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5312, "b_util": 0.5651, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.672, "b_util": 0.6101, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6582, "b_util": 0.5404, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.6028, "b_util": 0.5929, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3768, "b_util": 0.4017, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5823, "b_util": 0.595, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.6087, "b_util": 0.599, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6889, "b_util": 0.5233, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.4216, "b_util": 0.4819, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6572, "b_util": 0.5902, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.3014, "b_util": 0.3189, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6751, "b_util": 0.5807, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.3925, "b_util": 0.3224, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.6403, "b_util": 0.5746, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6264, "b_util": 0.5681, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.3785, "b_util": 0.4109, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.3934, "b_util": 0.4319, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5171, "b_util": 0.5883, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.4436, "b_util": 0.4628, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.1828, "b_util": 0.245, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5067, "b_util": 0.509, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5424, "b_util": 0.6032, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5444, "b_util": 0.6295, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6377, "b_util": 0.5784, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.6065, "b_util": 0.6095, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2572, "b_util": 0.3156, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.538, "b_util": 0.6659, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5518, "b_util": 0.6228, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6621, "b_util": 0.5185, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.358, "b_util": 0.4288, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5723, "b_util": 0.5519, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.3669, "b_util": 0.3476, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.5652, "b_util": 0.5474, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.171, "b_util": 0.1139, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.5596, "b_util": 0.563, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6109, "b_util": 0.5907, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.4212, "b_util": 0.4128, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4361, "b_util": 0.523, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.603, "b_util": 0.6498, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.5201, "b_util": 0.6064, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2647, "b_util": 0.2691, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.537, "b_util": 0.6229, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5784, "b_util": 0.6245, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5964, "b_util": 0.6155, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5747, "b_util": 0.5352, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.6038, "b_util": 0.5969, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3189, "b_util": 0.3179, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5079, "b_util": 0.5742, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5548, "b_util": 0.5739, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6361, "b_util": 0.5298, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.481, "b_util": 0.5707, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6017, "b_util": 0.576, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.151, "b_util": 0.1516, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6452, "b_util": 0.5533, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.3085, "b_util": 0.2808, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.6252, "b_util": 0.5857, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6557, "b_util": 0.5841, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.4621, "b_util": 0.5274, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4155, "b_util": 0.398, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5391, "b_util": 0.4798, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.2805, "b_util": 0.2378, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2729, "b_util": 0.247, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5681, "b_util": 0.4844, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.2811, "b_util": 0.2676, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5899, "b_util": 0.5194, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5892, "b_util": 0.4472, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.6186, "b_util": 0.5409, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.1523, "b_util": 0.1276, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.2607, "b_util": 0.2399, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.4633, "b_util": 0.424, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6465, "b_util": 0.5048, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.2341, "b_util": 0.2404, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.4788, "b_util": 0.4204, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2672, "b_util": 0.2966, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.4697, "b_util": 0.383, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.1483, "b_util": 0.1769, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7659, "b_util": 0.4515, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6241, "b_util": 0.4465, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.2332, "b_util": 0.2258, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.352, "b_util": 0.3604, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5868, "b_util": 0.5744, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.5058, "b_util": 0.5407, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.1958, "b_util": 0.2301, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5203, "b_util": 0.4637, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5409, "b_util": 0.5005, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5966, "b_util": 0.5548, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6239, "b_util": 0.4979, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.649, "b_util": 0.5862, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.1589, "b_util": 0.1178, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.4919, "b_util": 0.5119, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5922, "b_util": 0.561, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.668, "b_util": 0.4975, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.2218, "b_util": 0.2009, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5914, "b_util": 0.5098, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.21, "b_util": 0.234, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6823, "b_util": 0.5506, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2177, "b_util": 0.2054, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7318, "b_util": 0.4314, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6632, "b_util": 0.5576, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.313, "b_util": 0.288, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.456, "b_util": 0.4604, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.6486, "b_util": 0.6081, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.5767, "b_util": 0.6478, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.1919, "b_util": 0.2652, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5463, "b_util": 0.6481, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5469, "b_util": 0.5821, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5982, "b_util": 0.593, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6499, "b_util": 0.5097, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5805, "b_util": 0.5535, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3012, "b_util": 0.3037, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.539, "b_util": 0.5958, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5816, "b_util": 0.5719, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6558, "b_util": 0.4684, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.3937, "b_util": 0.4512, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6259, "b_util": 0.5595, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2372, "b_util": 0.2745, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.646, "b_util": 0.5434, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2998, "b_util": 0.292, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.61, "b_util": 0.5288, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6701, "b_util": 0.5761, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.401, "b_util": 0.4245, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4646, "b_util": 0.6076, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5215, "b_util": 0.6485, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.4948, "b_util": 0.7051, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.3046, "b_util": 0.383, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.4793, "b_util": 0.6674, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.4956, "b_util": 0.6619, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.4897, "b_util": 0.6456, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6366, "b_util": 0.5662, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5879, "b_util": 0.6326, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3549, "b_util": 0.4635, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.4983, "b_util": 0.692, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5031, "b_util": 0.6446, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6356, "b_util": 0.5366, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.4858, "b_util": 0.6927, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6074, "b_util": 0.5524, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2116, "b_util": 0.27, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.5785, "b_util": 0.5642, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2574, "b_util": 0.2531, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.6206, "b_util": 0.6821, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.607, "b_util": 0.6145, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.4622, "b_util": 0.629, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.3715, "b_util": 0.3796, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.6337, "b_util": 0.5972, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.4201, "b_util": 0.3592, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.1445, "b_util": 0.1634, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.3714, "b_util": 0.3933, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5802, "b_util": 0.5293, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.6541, "b_util": 0.5258, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5044, "b_util": 0.4432, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.6362, "b_util": 0.5472, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.461, "b_util": 0.5013, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5185, "b_util": 0.4929, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5699, "b_util": 0.5408, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.7121, "b_util": 0.5039, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.2325, "b_util": 0.246, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5123, "b_util": 0.4639, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1288, "b_util": 0.132, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6498, "b_util": 0.5241, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2615, "b_util": 0.2234, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.8014, "b_util": 0.4296, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6454, "b_util": 0.5056, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.4119, "b_util": 0.4669, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.393, "b_util": 0.4805, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5118, "b_util": 0.5442, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.4881, "b_util": 0.567, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2878, "b_util": 0.3362, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.4558, "b_util": 0.5259, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5446, "b_util": 0.5753, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5796, "b_util": 0.6131, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5561, "b_util": 0.5147, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5756, "b_util": 0.5642, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.1829, "b_util": 0.226, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5639, "b_util": 0.5918, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5359, "b_util": 0.5812, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.5899, "b_util": 0.5924, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.1567, "b_util": 0.131, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5348, "b_util": 0.5544, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2344, "b_util": 0.2519, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.5685, "b_util": 0.575, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2211, "b_util": 0.2435, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.5558, "b_util": 0.6001, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.5617, "b_util": 0.6012, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.2291, "b_util": 0.2379, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.2668, "b_util": 0.2377, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.4152, "b_util": 0.3867, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.2616, "b_util": 0.2554, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.37, "b_util": 0.3459, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.3686, "b_util": 0.3529, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.3733, "b_util": 0.3426, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.4478, "b_util": 0.344, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.3385, "b_util": 0.2789, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.4412, "b_util": 0.367, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.1388, "b_util": 0.1286, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5108, "b_util": 0.4616, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.505, "b_util": 0.4575, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.5665, "b_util": 0.3803, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.1328, "b_util": 0.1229, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.4524, "b_util": 0.3607, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1683, "b_util": 0.1453, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.2418, "b_util": 0.245, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.1999, "b_util": 0.1622, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7952, "b_util": 0.3976, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.7215, "b_util": 0.4896, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.3029, "b_util": 0.3054, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4917, "b_util": 0.6172, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5309, "b_util": 0.6384, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.4341, "b_util": 0.5423, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2466, "b_util": 0.2751, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.4973, "b_util": 0.593, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5455, "b_util": 0.6267, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5787, "b_util": 0.6256, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5704, "b_util": 0.6229, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5677, "b_util": 0.6548, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3186, "b_util": 0.3445, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5168, "b_util": 0.6323, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5437, "b_util": 0.6206, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.5838, "b_util": 0.5934, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.5119, "b_util": 0.6681, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6104, "b_util": 0.5746, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2058, "b_util": 0.2692, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.571, "b_util": 0.5835, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.3894, "b_util": 0.4655, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.5416, "b_util": 0.6681, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.5475, "b_util": 0.6009, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.4614, "b_util": 0.5686, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.2664, "b_util": 0.3029, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.3359, "b_util": 0.3216, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.326, "b_util": 0.3024, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2147, "b_util": 0.2312, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.2554, "b_util": 0.2093, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.4121, "b_util": 0.3883, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.414, "b_util": 0.3847, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.4831, "b_util": 0.3891, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.4457, "b_util": 0.3731, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.1496, "b_util": 0.1338, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.1799, "b_util": 0.1805, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5851, "b_util": 0.4734, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.3242, "b_util": 0.2852, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.2428, "b_util": 0.2243, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.2392, "b_util": 0.1882, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2902, "b_util": 0.37, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.4585, "b_util": 0.4056, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.1997, "b_util": 0.1918, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.298, "b_util": 0.2959, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.5748, "b_util": 0.4017, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.2469, "b_util": 0.2442, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4319, "b_util": 0.7351, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5154, "b_util": 0.6337, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.3966, "b_util": 0.7217, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.3593, "b_util": 0.6644, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.412, "b_util": 0.6952, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.434, "b_util": 0.6909, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5382, "b_util": 0.6326, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6558, "b_util": 0.4845, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.541, "b_util": 0.5856, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3852, "b_util": 0.6271, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5163, "b_util": 0.6819, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5618, "b_util": 0.6397, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6422, "b_util": 0.4816, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.4024, "b_util": 0.7763, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.631, "b_util": 0.5716, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.3612, "b_util": 0.7284, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6291, "b_util": 0.5657, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2836, "b_util": 0.345, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.5825, "b_util": 0.6013, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.7192, "b_util": 0.62, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.3834, "b_util": 0.7627, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4667, "b_util": 0.6165, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5325, "b_util": 0.6102, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.472, "b_util": 0.5893, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2666, "b_util": 0.4048, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5039, "b_util": 0.5894, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5241, "b_util": 0.585, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5633, "b_util": 0.6426, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5861, "b_util": 0.5771, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5801, "b_util": 0.575, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3184, "b_util": 0.444, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.6077, "b_util": 0.693, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5361, "b_util": 0.5935, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6027, "b_util": 0.5562, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.4886, "b_util": 0.6228, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.554, "b_util": 0.575, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.3589, "b_util": 0.5229, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6204, "b_util": 0.5793, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.3168, "b_util": 0.3721, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.5734, "b_util": 0.5617, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6126, "b_util": 0.5964, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.4426, "b_util": 0.5779, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.2947, "b_util": 0.3486, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5407, "b_util": 0.4856, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.3289, "b_util": 0.287, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2998, "b_util": 0.2708, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.3474, "b_util": 0.3577, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.4804, "b_util": 0.4566, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.6889, "b_util": 0.5475, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.3978, "b_util": 0.4224, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5219, "b_util": 0.4377, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2301, "b_util": 0.2471, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5628, "b_util": 0.5167, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5608, "b_util": 0.4705, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.7354, "b_util": 0.5151, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.1965, "b_util": 0.2082, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6127, "b_util": 0.4791, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1731, "b_util": 0.1889, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6533, "b_util": 0.5128, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2469, "b_util": 0.2716, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7924, "b_util": 0.3603, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.7741, "b_util": 0.5048, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.5472, "b_util": 0.5656, "deal_rate": 0.65 } ] }, "buyers_market": { "wall_seconds": 19.1, "seller_pressure": 1.5, "buyer_pressure": 1.0, "rankings": [ { "name": "SNHP", "avg": 0.5103631779246367, "med": 0.5393163644865221, "min": 0.2881178614169299, "max": 0.6468757257077955, "ci_lo": 0.4669368821854093, "ci_hi": 0.5523330738002497, "elo": 1308.6061200892334, "wins": 1, "ties": 0, "losses": 19 }, { "name": "Deadline Exploiter", "avg": 0.5090516530387051, "med": 0.5791946954051708, "min": 0.18148174520558522, "max": 0.8302552397314295, "ci_lo": 0.4274540192882411, "ci_hi": 0.5920532323486092, "elo": 1683.163996410782, "wins": 18, "ties": 0, "losses": 2 }, { "name": "The Closer", "avg": 0.5016927906993924, "med": 0.5510250834148449, "min": 0.1698139836592697, "max": 0.6874454517769422, "ci_lo": 0.42696128725833693, "ci_hi": 0.5687194287443073, "elo": 1475.0921447050343, "wins": 9, "ties": 0, "losses": 11 }, { "name": "Fairness Norm", "avg": 0.4997348460568013, "med": 0.5373247215514759, "min": 0.20138306000487083, "max": 0.6132357058076775, "ci_lo": 0.4524650081620059, "ci_hi": 0.5372562920349792, "elo": 1229.6125246966471, "wins": 4, "ties": 0, "losses": 16 }, { "name": "GoodCop/BadCop", "avg": 0.49949890305980715, "med": 0.540093786167552, "min": 0.18594008351689487, "max": 0.6952141347579729, "ci_lo": 0.42056443193319215, "ci_hi": 0.5677108822166296, "elo": 1556.8752659380543, "wins": 12, "ties": 0, "losses": 8 }, { "name": "Logroller", "avg": 0.49592262212562804, "med": 0.5571175768985862, "min": 0.17392381389006514, "max": 0.7006392835980925, "ci_lo": 0.42260962133690955, "ci_hi": 0.5627238852776603, "elo": 1467.5943650869121, "wins": 8, "ties": 0, "losses": 12 }, { "name": "Aspiration", "avg": 0.49073525389445005, "med": 0.5406945285203245, "min": 0.12851716217211634, "max": 0.8486877378408602, "ci_lo": 0.4034100791502809, "ci_hi": 0.5767015393582854, "elo": 1684.464214599176, "wins": 17, "ties": 0, "losses": 3 }, { "name": "Principled", "avg": 0.4867207024136256, "med": 0.5647412399814188, "min": 0.19709144026226966, "max": 0.6319889524262944, "ci_lo": 0.4202583919673133, "ci_hi": 0.5445047305305325, "elo": 1381.8091497573212, "wins": 7, "ties": 0, "losses": 13 }, { "name": "Tactical Empath", "avg": 0.48412304304871573, "med": 0.5326004135047745, "min": 0.20647889776298586, "max": 0.6672467448853258, "ci_lo": 0.42570987471739286, "ci_hi": 0.5388753750609854, "elo": 1295.8570811259015, "wins": 4, "ties": 1, "losses": 15 }, { "name": "Sunk Cost", "avg": 0.47833427645816506, "med": 0.4684894309686619, "min": 0.24972424505729476, "max": 0.6493371371845893, "ci_lo": 0.42944465213708, "ci_hi": 0.5311994658230828, "elo": 1309.5580943165187, "wins": 5, "ties": 0, "losses": 15 }, { "name": "Nibbler", "avg": 0.4777051877893889, "med": 0.4998950788699413, "min": 0.20815995988884103, "max": 0.7032763677390333, "ci_lo": 0.40839646438893684, "ci_hi": 0.5470610491852028, "elo": 1526.1561065156725, "wins": 11, "ties": 0, "losses": 9 }, { "name": "Cialdini", "avg": 0.4770202951448021, "med": 0.5795550217623798, "min": 0.14135809903592103, "max": 0.7263561529748581, "ci_lo": 0.3955314030013118, "ci_hi": 0.5571797385375811, "elo": 1645.8124524037305, "wins": 13, "ties": 1, "losses": 6 }, { "name": "Split-the-Diff", "avg": 0.46994269717294546, "med": 0.4886120425251036, "min": 0.16892352264735538, "max": 0.663456717931126, "ci_lo": 0.41363704054543193, "ci_hi": 0.5233106322377792, "elo": 1229.0070184840824, "wins": 3, "ties": 0, "losses": 17 }, { "name": "Fair Demand", "avg": 0.46751754986552296, "med": 0.530844273477428, "min": 0.18246393931398264, "max": 0.6223184415938324, "ci_lo": 0.40573021510016327, "ci_hi": 0.5234392919918889, "elo": 1284.946937626719, "wins": 4, "ties": 1, "losses": 15 }, { "name": "Anchorer", "avg": 0.4412280368320965, "med": 0.36789127130146937, "min": 0.13720380554787628, "max": 0.7442894471092455, "ci_lo": 0.3568897522376244, "ci_hi": 0.5321488194452536, "elo": 1703.626284672565, "wins": 14, "ties": 2, "losses": 4 }, { "name": "BATNA Bluffer", "avg": 0.43049744448531585, "med": 0.4364912079899459, "min": 0.19108423989705378, "max": 0.7729191372209943, "ci_lo": 0.3539318717005304, "ci_hi": 0.5115268519308422, "elo": 1644.896608230149, "wins": 10, "ties": 1, "losses": 9 }, { "name": "Soviet Patience", "avg": 0.3884068206542789, "med": 0.3764873866449921, "min": 0.13103505682562144, "max": 0.7993223169409326, "ci_lo": 0.3132395544655983, "ci_hi": 0.4770413462892917, "elo": 1683.8974322729878, "wins": 16, "ties": 0, "losses": 4 }, { "name": "Reciprocity", "avg": 0.37189699778944696, "med": 0.3479926799027115, "min": 0.1379361844526566, "max": 0.7585901748105296, "ci_lo": 0.285135034189441, "ci_hi": 0.46953932830436573, "elo": 1643.247874602991, "wins": 7, "ties": 1, "losses": 12 }, { "name": "Anchoring Bias", "avg": 0.36914992989238127, "med": 0.3321525306934835, "min": 0.11240923079435242, "max": 0.8411815867476566, "ci_lo": 0.29017231119273834, "ci_hi": 0.46236570256008475, "elo": 1567.4469884083292, "wins": 16, "ties": 0, "losses": 4 }, { "name": "Silent Hardliner", "avg": 0.3248565052400896, "med": 0.2565089908961035, "min": 0.16725771312864526, "max": 0.7326220343580003, "ci_lo": 0.2631309833231071, "ci_hi": 0.40721736090451394, "elo": 1653.6295722695143, "wins": 13, "ties": 3, "losses": 4 }, { "name": "Loss Averse", "avg": 0.3029573110193263, "med": 0.2984914964487319, "min": 0.138169095605057, "max": 0.5707482019232707, "ci_lo": 0.2501038519238215, "ci_hi": 0.35980007917736906, "elo": 1524.6997677876782, "wins": 13, "ties": 0, "losses": 7 } ], "pairwise": [ { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.2606, "b_util": 0.2925, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.6416, "b_util": 0.542, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.2346, "b_util": 0.2311, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2066, "b_util": 0.2184, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.3679, "b_util": 0.2874, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.4974, "b_util": 0.4667, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5809, "b_util": 0.4896, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5854, "b_util": 0.4655, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.6508, "b_util": 0.5007, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2122, "b_util": 0.2605, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.2333, "b_util": 0.2308, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.616, "b_util": 0.5231, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.7376, "b_util": 0.4811, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.2774, "b_util": 0.2443, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.3557, "b_util": 0.2735, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1372, "b_util": 0.1346, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6806, "b_util": 0.5384, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2179, "b_util": 0.1887, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7182, "b_util": 0.4817, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.7443, "b_util": 0.5418, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.3094, "b_util": 0.306, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.3145, "b_util": 0.4115, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5562, "b_util": 0.5595, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.4317, "b_util": 0.4711, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2451, "b_util": 0.3041, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.4023, "b_util": 0.4765, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.4999, "b_util": 0.5357, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.6156, "b_util": 0.6143, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.642, "b_util": 0.5575, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5891, "b_util": 0.5551, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2576, "b_util": 0.256, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.4722, "b_util": 0.4549, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.6042, "b_util": 0.6165, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.7033, "b_util": 0.5376, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.2989, "b_util": 0.2938, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6086, "b_util": 0.5496, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2745, "b_util": 0.3854, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.634, "b_util": 0.5368, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2082, "b_util": 0.2356, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.6657, "b_util": 0.5468, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6551, "b_util": 0.5773, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.3531, "b_util": 0.3884, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.1923, "b_util": 0.1565, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.4229, "b_util": 0.3609, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.2716, "b_util": 0.3085, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2174, "b_util": 0.2387, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.2873, "b_util": 0.2784, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.4792, "b_util": 0.4389, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5198, "b_util": 0.5113, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5631, "b_util": 0.5064, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5553, "b_util": 0.4589, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3202, "b_util": 0.3849, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.4823, "b_util": 0.4591, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.4365, "b_util": 0.4359, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6642, "b_util": 0.486, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.2676, "b_util": 0.3057, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6671, "b_util": 0.5393, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1959, "b_util": 0.2031, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6429, "b_util": 0.5207, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.1911, "b_util": 0.1968, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7729, "b_util": 0.4795, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6505, "b_util": 0.5518, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.2403, "b_util": 0.2385, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.2024, "b_util": 0.2414, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.3227, "b_util": 0.3195, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.2905, "b_util": 0.3288, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.1907, "b_util": 0.2048, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.1673, "b_util": 0.1852, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.2355, "b_util": 0.2615, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.2071, "b_util": 0.2559, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.4072, "b_util": 0.3518, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.3634, "b_util": 0.2699, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2213, "b_util": 0.2528, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.2737, "b_util": 0.2178, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.4357, "b_util": 0.4138, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.7326, "b_util": 0.5254, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.2262, "b_util": 0.2237, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.1841, "b_util": 0.1989, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1955, "b_util": 0.1976, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.2901, "b_util": 0.2759, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2447, "b_util": 0.2576, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7129, "b_util": 0.3991, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6621, "b_util": 0.4901, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.2565, "b_util": 0.2325, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.1622, "b_util": 0.1503, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.4782, "b_util": 0.4336, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.1388, "b_util": 0.1412, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.1632, "b_util": 0.1997, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.2292, "b_util": 0.1708, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.2069, "b_util": 0.2111, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5439, "b_util": 0.5045, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.4567, "b_util": 0.3497, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5337, "b_util": 0.5243, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.1461, "b_util": 0.1365, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.348, "b_util": 0.3223, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.6375, "b_util": 0.5646, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.7191, "b_util": 0.4907, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.1696, "b_util": 0.1958, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.3552, "b_util": 0.343, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1379, "b_util": 0.1508, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.5892, "b_util": 0.5095, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.1743, "b_util": 0.2033, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7586, "b_util": 0.492, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6714, "b_util": 0.5306, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.1899, "b_util": 0.1997, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.3109, "b_util": 0.3164, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5382, "b_util": 0.5396, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.5401, "b_util": 0.6138, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.1859, "b_util": 0.2111, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5079, "b_util": 0.5328, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.6061, "b_util": 0.6147, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.6197, "b_util": 0.6095, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6952, "b_util": 0.5592, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.6206, "b_util": 0.5844, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2849, "b_util": 0.3259, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5175, "b_util": 0.4919, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.6258, "b_util": 0.6063, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6444, "b_util": 0.5022, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.4055, "b_util": 0.4937, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6468, "b_util": 0.5869, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2038, "b_util": 0.1999, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6612, "b_util": 0.5423, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2044, "b_util": 0.2344, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.656, "b_util": 0.5344, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6421, "b_util": 0.5406, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.3721, "b_util": 0.4135, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4818, "b_util": 0.586, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.551, "b_util": 0.5609, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.4344, "b_util": 0.4805, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.3478, "b_util": 0.3856, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5282, "b_util": 0.6241, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5133, "b_util": 0.5739, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.6004, "b_util": 0.5907, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6614, "b_util": 0.5168, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.6184, "b_util": 0.5954, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.1698, "b_util": 0.1924, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5886, "b_util": 0.6385, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.6148, "b_util": 0.6041, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6557, "b_util": 0.5194, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.3003, "b_util": 0.3569, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6256, "b_util": 0.562, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2142, "b_util": 0.2491, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6549, "b_util": 0.54, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.202, "b_util": 0.21, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.6874, "b_util": 0.5425, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6803, "b_util": 0.5748, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.4052, "b_util": 0.4646, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4148, "b_util": 0.4581, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5326, "b_util": 0.5985, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.5674, "b_util": 0.6418, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2744, "b_util": 0.3127, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5295, "b_util": 0.5902, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.3798, "b_util": 0.4085, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5618, "b_util": 0.6341, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5539, "b_util": 0.5433, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.581, "b_util": 0.6171, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2493, "b_util": 0.3152, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.477, "b_util": 0.6403, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5799, "b_util": 0.6451, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6554, "b_util": 0.5343, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.4203, "b_util": 0.4797, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6104, "b_util": 0.5186, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.326, "b_util": 0.3804, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.615, "b_util": 0.5381, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2065, "b_util": 0.2209, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.5562, "b_util": 0.6289, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6672, "b_util": 0.6133, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.4083, "b_util": 0.4221, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4349, "b_util": 0.5197, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5711, "b_util": 0.6295, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.3933, "b_util": 0.4803, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2545, "b_util": 0.3194, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.552, "b_util": 0.6302, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5432, "b_util": 0.6371, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5826, "b_util": 0.6391, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5962, "b_util": 0.5805, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.57, "b_util": 0.5925, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3624, "b_util": 0.3838, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5712, "b_util": 0.6079, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5647, "b_util": 0.5837, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6266, "b_util": 0.5037, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.4528, "b_util": 0.5255, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.632, "b_util": 0.5336, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2293, "b_util": 0.3066, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6207, "b_util": 0.5733, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2482, "b_util": 0.3086, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.6004, "b_util": 0.5685, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.618, "b_util": 0.5738, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.1971, "b_util": 0.2401, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.3957, "b_util": 0.3745, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.3765, "b_util": 0.3532, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.2287, "b_util": 0.2241, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2618, "b_util": 0.3014, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.3535, "b_util": 0.3384, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.4287, "b_util": 0.4298, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.4718, "b_util": 0.4559, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.546, "b_util": 0.4549, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.4734, "b_util": 0.3816, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.1597, "b_util": 0.1854, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.2488, "b_util": 0.2511, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.4122, "b_util": 0.4238, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6328, "b_util": 0.4564, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.1923, "b_util": 0.2472, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5635, "b_util": 0.4081, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.131, "b_util": 0.1488, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.3681, "b_util": 0.3469, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2578, "b_util": 0.2456, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7993, "b_util": 0.4459, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6664, "b_util": 0.557, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.1884, "b_util": 0.1778, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.1896, "b_util": 0.1908, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.6485, "b_util": 0.6346, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.3748, "b_util": 0.3833, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2718, "b_util": 0.2283, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.4178, "b_util": 0.4627, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5882, "b_util": 0.5686, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.643, "b_util": 0.5967, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6045, "b_util": 0.5249, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5884, "b_util": 0.5825, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3625, "b_util": 0.4141, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.6144, "b_util": 0.6183, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5775, "b_util": 0.5445, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.7047, "b_util": 0.5159, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.27, "b_util": 0.2663, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5796, "b_util": 0.5623, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1562, "b_util": 0.1167, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6566, "b_util": 0.5174, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.1414, "b_util": 0.1237, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7264, "b_util": 0.5262, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6793, "b_util": 0.5883, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.2223, "b_util": 0.2632, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4161, "b_util": 0.4465, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.581, "b_util": 0.604, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.4972, "b_util": 0.5842, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2531, "b_util": 0.2964, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5588, "b_util": 0.5905, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5231, "b_util": 0.5289, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5934, "b_util": 0.5874, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6508, "b_util": 0.5563, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.6353, "b_util": 0.5881, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.1739, "b_util": 0.1954, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5506, "b_util": 0.5733, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5571, "b_util": 0.6071, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6575, "b_util": 0.4758, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.3475, "b_util": 0.3555, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5991, "b_util": 0.5968, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.194, "b_util": 0.1885, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6712, "b_util": 0.5809, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2383, "b_util": 0.2449, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.607, "b_util": 0.5574, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.7006, "b_util": 0.5676, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.4087, "b_util": 0.4903, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4551, "b_util": 0.667, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5067, "b_util": 0.6296, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.4413, "b_util": 0.5968, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.3069, "b_util": 0.4239, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.4636, "b_util": 0.6319, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.4911, "b_util": 0.6678, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5737, "b_util": 0.6229, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6635, "b_util": 0.5292, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5211, "b_util": 0.6101, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3317, "b_util": 0.4395, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.4886, "b_util": 0.6563, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.4806, "b_util": 0.6483, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6233, "b_util": 0.523, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.4372, "b_util": 0.6279, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5833, "b_util": 0.5716, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1689, "b_util": 0.2412, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6154, "b_util": 0.5934, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2402, "b_util": 0.3107, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.5411, "b_util": 0.676, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.5748, "b_util": 0.6367, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.3606, "b_util": 0.4615, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.297, "b_util": 0.373, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.607, "b_util": 0.5652, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.5954, "b_util": 0.5422, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.1978, "b_util": 0.2181, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5684, "b_util": 0.5655, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.461, "b_util": 0.4468, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5995, "b_util": 0.522, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.506, "b_util": 0.4246, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.6401, "b_util": 0.5466, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3048, "b_util": 0.3441, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5792, "b_util": 0.5352, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.6314, "b_util": 0.5529, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6846, "b_util": 0.4704, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.4173, "b_util": 0.4448, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6316, "b_util": 0.5742, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1815, "b_util": 0.1599, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6943, "b_util": 0.5353, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.206, "b_util": 0.242, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.8303, "b_util": 0.4554, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.7627, "b_util": 0.579, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.2942, "b_util": 0.2804, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.3535, "b_util": 0.3839, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5708, "b_util": 0.58, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.4704, "b_util": 0.4707, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2668, "b_util": 0.3169, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.3863, "b_util": 0.4312, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5308, "b_util": 0.5389, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5796, "b_util": 0.5878, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5198, "b_util": 0.576, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5654, "b_util": 0.5944, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.4, "b_util": 0.4798, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5356, "b_util": 0.5378, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5685, "b_util": 0.5806, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.5509, "b_util": 0.5232, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.1825, "b_util": 0.2056, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6045, "b_util": 0.5695, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2385, "b_util": 0.3392, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.5972, "b_util": 0.5699, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.269, "b_util": 0.3515, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.5898, "b_util": 0.5932, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6223, "b_util": 0.5789, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.4157, "b_util": 0.4846, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.2681, "b_util": 0.2776, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.3322, "b_util": 0.2449, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.2136, "b_util": 0.2049, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.1523, "b_util": 0.1925, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.264, "b_util": 0.2735, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.4346, "b_util": 0.369, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.4881, "b_util": 0.4554, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.455, "b_util": 0.3832, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.3708, "b_util": 0.3257, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.1124, "b_util": 0.178, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.2241, "b_util": 0.2516, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.458, "b_util": 0.4368, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6703, "b_util": 0.4797, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.1528, "b_util": 0.1672, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.4286, "b_util": 0.3462, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2217, "b_util": 0.2481, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6067, "b_util": 0.4415, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.127, "b_util": 0.158, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.8412, "b_util": 0.4079, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6593, "b_util": 0.4322, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.2714, "b_util": 0.2704, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4639, "b_util": 0.5996, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5789, "b_util": 0.6455, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.4562, "b_util": 0.5383, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.3625, "b_util": 0.468, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5327, "b_util": 0.6423, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5265, "b_util": 0.6351, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5399, "b_util": 0.6061, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5753, "b_util": 0.6362, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.569, "b_util": 0.6344, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3738, "b_util": 0.4455, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5816, "b_util": 0.6886, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5373, "b_util": 0.6533, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.5892, "b_util": 0.6122, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.4684, "b_util": 0.6462, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5509, "b_util": 0.6166, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2014, "b_util": 0.1804, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.5944, "b_util": 0.6312, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.3888, "b_util": 0.4219, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.5469, "b_util": 0.5742, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6132, "b_util": 0.5847, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.4436, "b_util": 0.5949, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.1792, "b_util": 0.2001, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.1382, "b_util": 0.1766, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.3192, "b_util": 0.3336, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2148, "b_util": 0.1893, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.3288, "b_util": 0.2991, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.4301, "b_util": 0.4633, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.2648, "b_util": 0.3152, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.2985, "b_util": 0.3023, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.3733, "b_util": 0.289, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.1702, "b_util": 0.1841, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.2733, "b_util": 0.2907, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.4644, "b_util": 0.4429, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.3514, "b_util": 0.3143, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.1405, "b_util": 0.154, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.4501, "b_util": 0.3859, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1947, "b_util": 0.22, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.3161, "b_util": 0.3287, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.1724, "b_util": 0.1994, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.5707, "b_util": 0.4341, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.5491, "b_util": 0.4243, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.1623, "b_util": 0.1784, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.416, "b_util": 0.7533, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.4988, "b_util": 0.6587, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.3608, "b_util": 0.7309, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.373, "b_util": 0.7324, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.399, "b_util": 0.6843, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.4685, "b_util": 0.6466, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.55, "b_util": 0.6542, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5997, "b_util": 0.598, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5709, "b_util": 0.5928, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3677, "b_util": 0.6482, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.4073, "b_util": 0.7043, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5802, "b_util": 0.6382, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6493, "b_util": 0.5107, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.3352, "b_util": 0.7019, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6347, "b_util": 0.5435, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.3438, "b_util": 0.6863, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6493, "b_util": 0.5729, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2497, "b_util": 0.2785, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.5865, "b_util": 0.5956, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6177, "b_util": 0.5848, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.3869, "b_util": 0.772, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4691, "b_util": 0.6468, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.579, "b_util": 0.6495, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.4707, "b_util": 0.587, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.5133, "b_util": 0.6436, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.4879, "b_util": 0.6365, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5386, "b_util": 0.606, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5486, "b_util": 0.6027, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6134, "b_util": 0.5213, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5801, "b_util": 0.5829, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2881, "b_util": 0.422, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.548, "b_util": 0.646, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5393, "b_util": 0.5783, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6375, "b_util": 0.5265, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.4814, "b_util": 0.6134, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5641, "b_util": 0.5538, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.3718, "b_util": 0.6123, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.5839, "b_util": 0.5716, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2887, "b_util": 0.3926, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.5888, "b_util": 0.5799, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6469, "b_util": 0.5869, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.3784, "b_util": 0.5953, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.3805, "b_util": 0.412, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5407, "b_util": 0.5049, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.3289, "b_util": 0.3763, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.1932, "b_util": 0.2461, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.3661, "b_util": 0.3768, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5751, "b_util": 0.5207, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.6827, "b_util": 0.5456, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5699, "b_util": 0.4871, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5921, "b_util": 0.4341, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.1366, "b_util": 0.1169, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.4121, "b_util": 0.4725, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5752, "b_util": 0.47, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.7122, "b_util": 0.4833, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.4647, "b_util": 0.4269, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.7024, "b_util": 0.4853, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1285, "b_util": 0.1222, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.7075, "b_util": 0.5168, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.3122, "b_util": 0.2452, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.8487, "b_util": 0.456, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.7018, "b_util": 0.4772, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.3744, "b_util": 0.4659, "deal_rate": 0.55 } ] }, "sellers_market": { "wall_seconds": 20.3, "seller_pressure": 1.0, "buyer_pressure": 1.5, "rankings": [ { "name": "SNHP", "avg": 0.5131222800979272, "med": 0.5226300310248871, "min": 0.2643349471391913, "max": 0.6226263112368721, "ci_lo": 0.4736541011432454, "ci_hi": 0.5480975985812494, "elo": 1311.575932875889, "wins": 2, "ties": 1, "losses": 17 }, { "name": "Fairness Norm", "avg": 0.5008824805856432, "med": 0.5486730143668375, "min": 0.21800106635555924, "max": 0.6353330199695808, "ci_lo": 0.44689802621356056, "ci_hi": 0.5474967694682789, "elo": 1287.2685733675842, "wins": 2, "ties": 0, "losses": 18 }, { "name": "Aspiration", "avg": 0.49794331046307483, "med": 0.5205409730880324, "min": 0.12066803160626868, "max": 0.8662962789534621, "ci_lo": 0.4081068460414834, "ci_hi": 0.5906531038658221, "elo": 1690.6007466494057, "wins": 16, "ties": 0, "losses": 4 }, { "name": "The Closer", "avg": 0.4962530975265564, "med": 0.5625881734015343, "min": 0.2203493869239692, "max": 0.6649579823313067, "ci_lo": 0.4254078127099773, "ci_hi": 0.5588530930099226, "elo": 1433.26634437648, "wins": 7, "ties": 1, "losses": 12 }, { "name": "GoodCop/BadCop", "avg": 0.49380070593224223, "med": 0.5319313363989312, "min": 0.1683188798428058, "max": 0.702540586523485, "ci_lo": 0.417694567856513, "ci_hi": 0.5635472419068496, "elo": 1603.652721219037, "wins": 13, "ties": 0, "losses": 7 }, { "name": "Split-the-Diff", "avg": 0.49351381150917384, "med": 0.5083784366977439, "min": 0.2824095049898661, "max": 0.6518112206865219, "ci_lo": 0.44766237268448505, "ci_hi": 0.5384420256778165, "elo": 1249.5117397621987, "wins": 3, "ties": 0, "losses": 17 }, { "name": "Principled", "avg": 0.49296745270770864, "med": 0.5667829255934123, "min": 0.1819075354372175, "max": 0.6524229787779892, "ci_lo": 0.42585135350324327, "ci_hi": 0.549987678391225, "elo": 1447.600329633938, "wins": 6, "ties": 0, "losses": 14 }, { "name": "Sunk Cost", "avg": 0.4895713819943662, "med": 0.48750572532213093, "min": 0.27168755906033965, "max": 0.7157541779764065, "ci_lo": 0.43530376856120817, "ci_hi": 0.5447996843028642, "elo": 1344.0684265349125, "wins": 5, "ties": 0, "losses": 15 }, { "name": "Tactical Empath", "avg": 0.4849228968139924, "med": 0.5000509611522056, "min": 0.2252539533938956, "max": 0.6425976178496121, "ci_lo": 0.42844509115256696, "ci_hi": 0.5334302942884999, "elo": 1320.542732460508, "wins": 4, "ties": 0, "losses": 16 }, { "name": "Nibbler", "avg": 0.48417641627561575, "med": 0.5570530887890696, "min": 0.1592917108775538, "max": 0.6881982701583057, "ci_lo": 0.408020293139733, "ci_hi": 0.5534797089730707, "elo": 1506.0836796271847, "wins": 10, "ties": 1, "losses": 9 }, { "name": "Logroller", "avg": 0.48191390109955934, "med": 0.5485836663359518, "min": 0.14277119468363775, "max": 0.6604806598663668, "ci_lo": 0.4081012676740329, "ci_hi": 0.5447634983327311, "elo": 1535.4462544058292, "wins": 8, "ties": 0, "losses": 12 }, { "name": "Cialdini", "avg": 0.4767627963688212, "med": 0.5683438457955362, "min": 0.13486264934603426, "max": 0.7405242372034542, "ci_lo": 0.39030189619104244, "ci_hi": 0.5621623982968912, "elo": 1577.6461183374015, "wins": 12, "ties": 2, "losses": 6 }, { "name": "Anchorer", "avg": 0.472968942678614, "med": 0.47871579991820856, "min": 0.24775352583799543, "max": 0.736619983981556, "ci_lo": 0.4065867316970698, "ci_hi": 0.5399048007732692, "elo": 1576.8360154706254, "wins": 16, "ties": 0, "losses": 4 }, { "name": "Deadline Exploiter", "avg": 0.4698996214158565, "med": 0.524703587814479, "min": 0.1544848634129172, "max": 0.8356353704236463, "ci_lo": 0.38304223611482746, "ci_hi": 0.5563245293421575, "elo": 1691.9434611968622, "wins": 16, "ties": 0, "losses": 4 }, { "name": "BATNA Bluffer", "avg": 0.4609487397447781, "med": 0.3588723755442764, "min": 0.21028596811018216, "max": 0.8111946830088186, "ci_lo": 0.38803254931861075, "ci_hi": 0.5399819775453135, "elo": 1638.185560492239, "wins": 15, "ties": 0, "losses": 5 }, { "name": "Fair Demand", "avg": 0.44241277834706155, "med": 0.5139569943224076, "min": 0.14219300296342371, "max": 0.6826133647937641, "ci_lo": 0.37694135879142204, "ci_hi": 0.5032780593994104, "elo": 1296.1847870226418, "wins": 2, "ties": 0, "losses": 18 }, { "name": "Soviet Patience", "avg": 0.42886154082096, "med": 0.4607544182651236, "min": 0.10840189434629471, "max": 0.7072438857611003, "ci_lo": 0.34008082410692875, "ci_hi": 0.5145274166661179, "elo": 1542.8552582543475, "wins": 13, "ties": 0, "losses": 7 }, { "name": "Reciprocity", "avg": 0.42257809370450444, "med": 0.43553984256150474, "min": 0.1573176859024878, "max": 0.7496965631248188, "ci_lo": 0.34258815034767315, "ci_hi": 0.5119171625499809, "elo": 1603.0211117461834, "wins": 10, "ties": 0, "losses": 10 }, { "name": "Anchoring Bias", "avg": 0.3809593906844407, "med": 0.3614913365558426, "min": 0.1934092317043231, "max": 0.8038101566501165, "ci_lo": 0.32340164682099465, "ci_hi": 0.4569056291120399, "elo": 1667.218266239168, "wins": 18, "ties": 0, "losses": 2 }, { "name": "Silent Hardliner", "avg": 0.3515294206601567, "med": 0.3029626116215504, "min": 0.12651247203671614, "max": 0.7580657498393182, "ci_lo": 0.2903260831040303, "ci_hi": 0.42512129643896723, "elo": 1575.6164678908747, "wins": 14, "ties": 2, "losses": 4 }, { "name": "Loss Averse", "avg": 0.3238138682603601, "med": 0.273555748989084, "min": 0.17018633032647704, "max": 0.6404710973570046, "ci_lo": 0.27334324304944085, "ci_hi": 0.3825945710355427, "elo": 1600.8754724366895, "wins": 14, "ties": 1, "losses": 5 } ], "pairwise": [ { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.3347, "b_util": 0.2902, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5616, "b_util": 0.5385, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.3626, "b_util": 0.294, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.3075, "b_util": 0.2707, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.4028, "b_util": 0.354, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.3186, "b_util": 0.3072, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.6232, "b_util": 0.5156, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.4787, "b_util": 0.3306, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5489, "b_util": 0.4779, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3666, "b_util": 0.3139, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5013, "b_util": 0.4756, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5122, "b_util": 0.4049, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.7149, "b_util": 0.4711, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.4792, "b_util": 0.4385, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.3673, "b_util": 0.3433, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2478, "b_util": 0.19, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.681, "b_util": 0.5001, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2546, "b_util": 0.2277, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7178, "b_util": 0.4154, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.7366, "b_util": 0.5436, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Anchorer", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.4143, "b_util": 0.4141, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4174, "b_util": 0.448, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.542, "b_util": 0.5754, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.2614, "b_util": 0.2361, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.3668, "b_util": 0.3847, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5571, "b_util": 0.525, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5363, "b_util": 0.4834, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.6487, "b_util": 0.6184, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5827, "b_util": 0.5023, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5959, "b_util": 0.5804, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.1922, "b_util": 0.1642, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5653, "b_util": 0.581, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.6231, "b_util": 0.5856, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6882, "b_util": 0.5229, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.3493, "b_util": 0.3776, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6264, "b_util": 0.5801, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2063, "b_util": 0.2814, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6317, "b_util": 0.5375, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.3021, "b_util": 0.2751, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.6802, "b_util": 0.5678, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6353, "b_util": 0.5778, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Nibbler", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.1593, "b_util": 0.2042, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.2103, "b_util": 0.1746, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.3397, "b_util": 0.3463, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.3493, "b_util": 0.277, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2494, "b_util": 0.2167, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5188, "b_util": 0.4499, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.3373, "b_util": 0.34, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5914, "b_util": 0.5307, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5801, "b_util": 0.4655, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.6205, "b_util": 0.4897, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2752, "b_util": 0.2605, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.3116, "b_util": 0.282, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5545, "b_util": 0.4981, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.7058, "b_util": 0.504, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.3264, "b_util": 0.2986, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5505, "b_util": 0.5004, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.3589, "b_util": 0.3213, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.7481, "b_util": 0.545, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2348, "b_util": 0.2167, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.8112, "b_util": 0.4943, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6825, "b_util": 0.5227, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "BATNA Bluffer", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.3238, "b_util": 0.2735, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.2144, "b_util": 0.2172, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.2304, "b_util": 0.2155, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.303, "b_util": 0.2957, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2354, "b_util": 0.2002, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.2153, "b_util": 0.148, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5114, "b_util": 0.4093, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.3586, "b_util": 0.305, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5135, "b_util": 0.3928, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.4538, "b_util": 0.3623, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2576, "b_util": 0.2419, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.2671, "b_util": 0.2338, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.3883, "b_util": 0.3498, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.4583, "b_util": 0.3294, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.1265, "b_util": 0.1339, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.3805, "b_util": 0.2947, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2017, "b_util": 0.1855, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.424, "b_util": 0.3658, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2642, "b_util": 0.2395, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7581, "b_util": 0.4957, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.5952, "b_util": 0.3468, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Silent Hardliner", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.225, "b_util": 0.204, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.3899, "b_util": 0.3782, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.6068, "b_util": 0.5366, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.2339, "b_util": 0.2085, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.1922, "b_util": 0.191, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.2129, "b_util": 0.1804, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5694, "b_util": 0.5441, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5538, "b_util": 0.504, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.4355, "b_util": 0.3717, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.6021, "b_util": 0.5363, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.1573, "b_util": 0.1457, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.2198, "b_util": 0.2301, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.541, "b_util": 0.4783, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6944, "b_util": 0.4877, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.3597, "b_util": 0.3935, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.4716, "b_util": 0.4306, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1762, "b_util": 0.178, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6521, "b_util": 0.5086, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2289, "b_util": 0.2061, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7497, "b_util": 0.4602, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6488, "b_util": 0.551, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Reciprocity", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.178, "b_util": 0.1569, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.5131, "b_util": 0.5596, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5486, "b_util": 0.5716, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.2682, "b_util": 0.2072, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2025, "b_util": 0.1522, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5319, "b_util": 0.5556, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5504, "b_util": 0.5335, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.6058, "b_util": 0.5955, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5318, "b_util": 0.5095, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.6299, "b_util": 0.5983, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2346, "b_util": 0.1902, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5016, "b_util": 0.5519, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.6074, "b_util": 0.5712, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6791, "b_util": 0.4746, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.4054, "b_util": 0.3874, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5824, "b_util": 0.5431, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1683, "b_util": 0.1643, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6647, "b_util": 0.5334, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.3116, "b_util": 0.2379, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7025, "b_util": 0.5834, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6982, "b_util": 0.5523, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "GoodCop/BadCop", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.4318, "b_util": 0.3763, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.3905, "b_util": 0.3655, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5891, "b_util": 0.6099, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.5114, "b_util": 0.5626, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2472, "b_util": 0.285, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5225, "b_util": 0.5342, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5626, "b_util": 0.5643, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.6148, "b_util": 0.6016, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6223, "b_util": 0.4933, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5966, "b_util": 0.6136, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3474, "b_util": 0.3366, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5621, "b_util": 0.5889, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.6057, "b_util": 0.6052, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6598, "b_util": 0.5149, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.2259, "b_util": 0.328, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6093, "b_util": 0.5765, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2203, "b_util": 0.1965, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.5899, "b_util": 0.5604, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2401, "b_util": 0.2291, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.665, "b_util": 0.5873, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6172, "b_util": 0.5449, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "The Closer", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.4218, "b_util": 0.4503, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4701, "b_util": 0.4723, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.4958, "b_util": 0.561, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.524, "b_util": 0.5481, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.272, "b_util": 0.3372, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.4917, "b_util": 0.5261, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.4864, "b_util": 0.5304, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5001, "b_util": 0.6189, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6426, "b_util": 0.5556, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5782, "b_util": 0.6404, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2677, "b_util": 0.2368, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5031, "b_util": 0.5975, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5383, "b_util": 0.6209, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.612, "b_util": 0.5842, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.401, "b_util": 0.4571, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5772, "b_util": 0.5487, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2253, "b_util": 0.2106, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.617, "b_util": 0.5543, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.3488, "b_util": 0.3256, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.567, "b_util": 0.6457, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.5904, "b_util": 0.5798, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Tactical Empath", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.4748, "b_util": 0.5451, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.444, "b_util": 0.5421, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5668, "b_util": 0.6219, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.4564, "b_util": 0.5504, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2633, "b_util": 0.2702, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.4952, "b_util": 0.5716, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5743, "b_util": 0.6683, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5847, "b_util": 0.5842, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6115, "b_util": 0.5995, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.6104, "b_util": 0.6031, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.1819, "b_util": 0.1904, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5546, "b_util": 0.6013, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5743, "b_util": 0.6076, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6462, "b_util": 0.557, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.3626, "b_util": 0.409, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6005, "b_util": 0.5777, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2507, "b_util": 0.2355, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6073, "b_util": 0.5918, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.3866, "b_util": 0.3786, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.6243, "b_util": 0.5943, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6524, "b_util": 0.6396, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Principled", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.3043, "b_util": 0.3148, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.2698, "b_util": 0.2691, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5641, "b_util": 0.4924, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.1668, "b_util": 0.1343, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2351, "b_util": 0.2272, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.4608, "b_util": 0.4105, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.1789, "b_util": 0.1934, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5649, "b_util": 0.4424, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5617, "b_util": 0.4121, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5709, "b_util": 0.3946, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2606, "b_util": 0.2798, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.4304, "b_util": 0.3688, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.6402, "b_util": 0.5015, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6339, "b_util": 0.4862, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.1084, "b_util": 0.1155, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.601, "b_util": 0.4818, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1877, "b_util": 0.2006, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6522, "b_util": 0.501, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2937, "b_util": 0.3077, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7072, "b_util": 0.3967, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6853, "b_util": 0.54, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Soviet Patience", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.2325, "b_util": 0.196, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.374, "b_util": 0.3016, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5683, "b_util": 0.5475, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.3292, "b_util": 0.3539, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.268, "b_util": 0.2769, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5132, "b_util": 0.503, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5933, "b_util": 0.5602, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.6288, "b_util": 0.5391, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.689, "b_util": 0.56, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.6326, "b_util": 0.584, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.1918, "b_util": 0.2078, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.4979, "b_util": 0.4679, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5869, "b_util": 0.5677, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6684, "b_util": 0.5183, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.1349, "b_util": 0.1314, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.644, "b_util": 0.5775, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2041, "b_util": 0.2096, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6584, "b_util": 0.5522, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.1415, "b_util": 0.1331, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.7405, "b_util": 0.5022, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.7071, "b_util": 0.566, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Cialdini", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.2402, "b_util": 0.2467, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4862, "b_util": 0.5319, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.589, "b_util": 0.5468, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.5002, "b_util": 0.5541, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.1428, "b_util": 0.1515, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5167, "b_util": 0.5727, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.524, "b_util": 0.5377, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5659, "b_util": 0.543, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5486, "b_util": 0.4559, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5859, "b_util": 0.5682, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2674, "b_util": 0.2637, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5599, "b_util": 0.5734, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5747, "b_util": 0.6073, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6605, "b_util": 0.5411, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.3421, "b_util": 0.3, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6168, "b_util": 0.5714, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1591, "b_util": 0.1475, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6349, "b_util": 0.5728, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2731, "b_util": 0.3217, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.612, "b_util": 0.5825, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6004, "b_util": 0.5479, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Logroller", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.36, "b_util": 0.4021, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.5067, "b_util": 0.6778, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5202, "b_util": 0.669, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.466, "b_util": 0.5602, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.3554, "b_util": 0.3889, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.4309, "b_util": 0.5904, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5084, "b_util": 0.653, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5258, "b_util": 0.6266, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6176, "b_util": 0.4993, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5348, "b_util": 0.6223, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2931, "b_util": 0.2652, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5326, "b_util": 0.6639, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.502, "b_util": 0.6464, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6206, "b_util": 0.5397, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.4811, "b_util": 0.6546, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6383, "b_util": 0.5503, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.3215, "b_util": 0.3572, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6518, "b_util": 0.5725, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2824, "b_util": 0.2648, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.5352, "b_util": 0.6491, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6013, "b_util": 0.6167, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Split-the-Diff", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.438, "b_util": 0.589, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.3308, "b_util": 0.2524, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5247, "b_util": 0.4205, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.181, "b_util": 0.2157, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2326, "b_util": 0.2098, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.3758, "b_util": 0.3412, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5207, "b_util": 0.4228, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.6994, "b_util": 0.6197, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5437, "b_util": 0.4353, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5715, "b_util": 0.487, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3153, "b_util": 0.3191, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5656, "b_util": 0.5096, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.6178, "b_util": 0.5931, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.7303, "b_util": 0.4854, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.3409, "b_util": 0.3585, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5761, "b_util": 0.5204, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.21, "b_util": 0.1665, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6494, "b_util": 0.5275, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2235, "b_util": 0.1209, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.8356, "b_util": 0.495, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6686, "b_util": 0.5287, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Deadline Exploiter", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.1545, "b_util": 0.1652, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4104, "b_util": 0.4627, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5414, "b_util": 0.6112, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.3996, "b_util": 0.413, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.1956, "b_util": 0.1755, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.3597, "b_util": 0.4138, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.4616, "b_util": 0.4722, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5651, "b_util": 0.6257, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5262, "b_util": 0.553, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5765, "b_util": 0.6175, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2406, "b_util": 0.2556, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.527, "b_util": 0.5627, "deal_rate": 0.8 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5677, "b_util": 0.6245, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.5883, "b_util": 0.5816, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.3476, "b_util": 0.3773, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.514, "b_util": 0.5233, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1422, "b_util": 0.1265, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.5667, "b_util": 0.5588, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.218, "b_util": 0.2348, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.5648, "b_util": 0.5704, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6826, "b_util": 0.5876, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fair Demand", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.2951, "b_util": 0.307, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.1934, "b_util": 0.19, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.4607, "b_util": 0.3611, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.1943, "b_util": 0.1749, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.3568, "b_util": 0.2989, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.2703, "b_util": 0.2552, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.3409, "b_util": 0.3017, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.3615, "b_util": 0.2582, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.2939, "b_util": 0.2495, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.4539, "b_util": 0.3299, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.3694, "b_util": 0.2964, "deal_rate": 0.2 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.2833, "b_util": 0.203, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.4995, "b_util": 0.4279, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.5416, "b_util": 0.4044, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.2344, "b_util": 0.22, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.4254, "b_util": 0.3267, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2365, "b_util": 0.2401, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.3827, "b_util": 0.3109, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.2138, "b_util": 0.1939, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.8038, "b_util": 0.3874, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.7068, "b_util": 0.4844, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Anchoring Bias", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.3771, "b_util": 0.3474, "deal_rate": 0.25 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.5138, "b_util": 0.6483, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5518, "b_util": 0.6297, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.5026, "b_util": 0.6388, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.3095, "b_util": 0.3626, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5113, "b_util": 0.6271, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5612, "b_util": 0.6419, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5541, "b_util": 0.6087, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.5511, "b_util": 0.5926, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5755, "b_util": 0.6022, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.4401, "b_util": 0.5338, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5487, "b_util": 0.6548, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5419, "b_util": 0.63, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6065, "b_util": 0.5542, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.4213, "b_util": 0.5695, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.6347, "b_util": 0.6023, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2535, "b_util": 0.2461, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.5784, "b_util": 0.5826, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.218, "b_util": 0.2019, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.5496, "b_util": 0.6099, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6353, "b_util": 0.588, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Fairness Norm", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.4597, "b_util": 0.5252, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4264, "b_util": 0.3934, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.4241, "b_util": 0.4071, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.2611, "b_util": 0.2337, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2616, "b_util": 0.2344, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.3082, "b_util": 0.3196, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.1702, "b_util": 0.1802, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.2537, "b_util": 0.2106, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.273, "b_util": 0.215, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.4321, "b_util": 0.3952, "deal_rate": 0.35 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2074, "b_util": 0.1753, "deal_rate": 0.05 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.2487, "b_util": 0.2102, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.2164, "b_util": 0.2447, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.4321, "b_util": 0.3564, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.2736, "b_util": 0.2704, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.4133, "b_util": 0.3265, "deal_rate": 0.3 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.1798, "b_util": 0.1486, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.2744, "b_util": 0.2192, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.245, "b_util": 0.205, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.6405, "b_util": 0.4406, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.5675, "b_util": 0.3999, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "Loss Averse", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.2909, "b_util": 0.2614, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.4228, "b_util": 0.7421, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.5276, "b_util": 0.6463, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.3437, "b_util": 0.7373, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.2717, "b_util": 0.4556, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.4411, "b_util": 0.7519, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.4875, "b_util": 0.7201, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.5443, "b_util": 0.6323, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.677, "b_util": 0.5959, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5426, "b_util": 0.626, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.385, "b_util": 0.5795, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.4103, "b_util": 0.7067, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5583, "b_util": 0.6544, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.7158, "b_util": 0.5151, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.3718, "b_util": 0.7702, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5913, "b_util": 0.5841, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.3423, "b_util": 0.5944, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.6762, "b_util": 0.5657, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.3752, "b_util": 0.4766, "deal_rate": 0.4 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.5902, "b_util": 0.5527, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.6491, "b_util": 0.5718, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Sunk Cost", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.3572, "b_util": 0.7455, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.485, "b_util": 0.5929, "deal_rate": 0.7 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.4863, "b_util": 0.5848, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.5226, "b_util": 0.6299, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.4127, "b_util": 0.4908, "deal_rate": 0.55 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5126, "b_util": 0.6509, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.5265, "b_util": 0.6254, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.6148, "b_util": 0.573, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6126, "b_util": 0.5779, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.5789, "b_util": 0.5934, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.4146, "b_util": 0.5741, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5134, "b_util": 0.6122, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.5806, "b_util": 0.6183, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.6226, "b_util": 0.5421, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.4591, "b_util": 0.6096, "deal_rate": 0.85 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5546, "b_util": 0.5927, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.2643, "b_util": 0.4724, "deal_rate": 0.45 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.597, "b_util": 0.58, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.4443, "b_util": 0.5033, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.5911, "b_util": 0.5562, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.5705, "b_util": 0.6048, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "SNHP", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.4115, "b_util": 0.5411, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Anchorer", "a_util": 0.5131, "b_util": 0.5023, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Nibbler", "a_util": 0.527, "b_util": 0.4705, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "BATNA Bluffer", "a_util": 0.4456, "b_util": 0.4891, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Silent Hardliner", "a_util": 0.1207, "b_util": 0.1142, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Reciprocity", "a_util": 0.5011, "b_util": 0.4711, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "GoodCop/BadCop", "a_util": 0.4977, "b_util": 0.418, "deal_rate": 0.5 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "The Closer", "a_util": 0.6173, "b_util": 0.4633, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Tactical Empath", "a_util": 0.6258, "b_util": 0.5514, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Principled", "a_util": 0.654, "b_util": 0.4856, "deal_rate": 0.75 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Soviet Patience", "a_util": 0.2853, "b_util": 0.2696, "deal_rate": 0.15 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Cialdini", "a_util": 0.5205, "b_util": 0.5087, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Logroller", "a_util": 0.6121, "b_util": 0.4967, "deal_rate": 0.65 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Split-the-Diff", "a_util": 0.7522, "b_util": 0.5035, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Deadline Exploiter", "a_util": 0.1282, "b_util": 0.145, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Fair Demand", "a_util": 0.5545, "b_util": 0.4428, "deal_rate": 0.6 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Anchoring Bias", "a_util": 0.22, "b_util": 0.2308, "deal_rate": 0.1 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Fairness Norm", "a_util": 0.7196, "b_util": 0.5217, "deal_rate": 0.95 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Loss Averse", "a_util": 0.1799, "b_util": 0.1618, "deal_rate": 0.0 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Sunk Cost", "a_util": 0.8663, "b_util": 0.4368, "deal_rate": 1.0 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "SNHP", "a_util": 0.7104, "b_util": 0.4904, "deal_rate": 0.9 }, { "a": "Aspiration", "b": "Aspiration", "a_util": 0.4055, "b_util": 0.4764, "deal_rate": 0.45 } ] } } }